Bike Shop Bikes vs. Online Bikes

Bike shops are vital and play an essential role in building and establishing biking communities.  But due to circumstances often out of their control, they are not the best place to purchase a bike for a child.  For various reasons, true “family bike” shops are hard to come by these days.  Shops generally cater to the high-end market focusing on either road, mountain or electric bikes, but rarely (if ever) kids. Yes, bike shops are FAR better than big-box stores or toy stores, but they are no longer the best place to buy a kids’ bike.

Kid-specific Bike Design

Over the past couple years, true kid-specific bikes have begun to flourish.  Instead of miniature adult bikes, bikes have been redesigned from top to bottom to specifically fit children’s bodies.  Frames are getting lighter, brakes are getting easier and bikes are getting narrower to fit the needs of a child.  Due to the specialized parts to make these bikes they are usually more expensive than bike shop bikes, but they do fit them better. Sadly, these advancements, such as a narrow build (q-factor), are rarely found on the kid’s bikes found in local bike shops?  Why? The profit margin on kid’s bikes is simply too small.

cnoc-16-review-q-factor

 

Bike manufacturers, such as Trek, Specialized, Giant, etc., are not in the business of designing bikes for kids. They put their focus on high-end, high-margin adult bikes and design kids bikes on the side. In addition, their kids’ bikes are often designed by someone who is not familiar with child-specific needs and may have never even taught a child to ride.  They simply just scale down an adult bike, make it look “cool” and call it good. Realizing that most buyers assume that if their company makes awesome adult bikes, they will also make awesome kids bikes, they allow their name to sell their bikes, not the design. Norco Bicycles out of Canada, however, is an exception, as their kids’ line of bikes is significantly better than those offered by other major brands (they ofter dual-hands brakes, a freewheel 16″ and better geometry).

Outside the US, the biking world is vastly different as there are many kid-specific manufacturers. Islabikes from the UK, WOOM from Austria, ByK Bikes from Australia and Spawn Cycles from Canada only design kid bikes. To them, kid bikes are not an afterthought, but rather their only thought. Seeing a lack of well-designed kids bikes in the US, all four companies now offer their bikes in the US online. Independent US kids-specific bike companies are also changing the game, Guardian Bikes, Stampede Bikes, Cleary BikesPello Bikes and Lil’Shredder are all based in the US and are also available online. (sidenote: I am NOT an affiliate of any of the companies listed!)

With their profits based solely on kids’ bikes, these companies have to rely on the design and functionality of their bikes, rather than their name alone.  Not available in bike shops, the technological advancements on these bikes are far superior to the kid’s bike larger bike brands are selling in the US. Most are lighter, have a lower center-of-gravity (lower bottom bracket w/smaller cranks), easy-pull, child-sized brake levers and are often narrower (use a child-specific crankset versus the standard adult-width crank).

 

16-bikes-Comparisons

Visiting a Local Bike Shop

Beyond the bikes, visiting some bike shops can be intimidating for families.  Again, this is not all bike shops, however finding a true “family bike shop” is becoming more difficult. In the vast majority of shops, high-profit adult bikes are given the prime floor space while kids’ bikes are often banished to the ceiling or small corners of the store (except maybe during the holiday season). Without the profit margin’s from these big sellers, the shops would likely go under, so it is completely understandable why shops are laid out as they are. But what the big-name bike manufacturers, as well as many shop owners (not all!), fail to realize it that brand loyalty goes a long way in families. Parents often don’t have the time or energy to travel from shop to shop, especially with kids in tow.  They want and need a one stop shop. If a shop provides amazing customer service and offers well-designed bikes for their entire family (kids included!), you’ll likely have all of their business for years to come.

Furthermore, employees are often quite knowledgeable on adult bikes, but rarely on kids’ bikes.  Kids require different geometries and setups than adults. Over the years, we have been told countless myths and incorrect information about kid’s bikes while visiting various shops (shopping as everyday parents, not Two Wheeling Tots).  Training wheels are not a replacement for balance bikes (especially for toddler and preschoolers), all 14″ bikes are not “crap”, kids CAN use hand brakes (when properly designed) and coaster brakes do more harm than good.

Sporting goods stores like REI, Dick’s and even Performance Bikes are in the same boat as local bike shops. To save money (and increase profit margins), their bikes are built with components sized for adults, making the bikes wider, heavier and with poor geometry. Like bike shops, their bikes are generally MUCH better than those at big-box stores but do not stand up next to those from online kid-specific bike manufacturers.

What’s the Solution? (for parents)

Don’t discount your local bike shop (they are still a great asset), but know what you want as well as what your child needs BEFORE you visit the shop. Knowing your child’s weight and their inseam will also help you determine if a bike is a good fit.  Don’t be afraid to ask questions.  Ask them to weight the bike without the training wheels and have them measure the bike minimum and maximum seat height.  Ask if a hand brake can be added to the bike (most kid’s bikes in bike shops don’t have them).  Lastly, if you feel that a bike available online would be better for your child, ask them how much they would charge for expert assembly and tuning.

What’s the Solution? (for bike shops)

Train your employees on the specific needs of kids. Be aware that balance bike graduates need to be able to touch the ground with almost their full foot in order to stop a bike. Like adults, consider the weight of the bike versus its rider.  A 20 lb. bike is half the weight of a 40 lb. child! Understand that kids naturally pedal backwards when learning to pedal, so coaster brakes often cause more harm than good. When possible, make kids’ bike more accessible and don’t banish them to the ceiling or corners.  Lastly, if a family can’t find a bike that works in your shop, be understanding and offer to assemble one they purchase online and be sure to help them try on helmets or gloves.

Bottom Line

Bike shop are vital to our communities and need our support, but when it comes to kids bikes, they can’t compete with bikes available online. Until Trek, Specialized, Giant and other big-name bike brands, step up their game in their kids’ lines, bikes shops hands are tied. If you prefer to purchase a bike at your local bike shop, Norco’s line of kids bikes is hand-downs the best compared to other major brands. Lastly, the expert tuning and bike assembly offered by your local shop, cannot be replaced, so be sure to utilize them when possible.

Bike Shop vs. Online Bikes Specs Comparison


There is no “best bike” for all kids as their age, weight, ability and where and how they ride all factor into finding the best bike for each child.  While nothing compares to actually riding a bike, many difference between online and bike shop bikes can be seen in the specs listed below. Most big-name brands don’t list all their specs online, so a portion of this chart is incomplete.  While we were able to test out bikes at bike shops, we weren’t able to get all the measurements we needed.  Complete explanations of specs provided below the chart.

16″ and 18″ Bike Comparison
Bike MSRP Weight (lb) Seat Height Brakes Q Factor Gain Ratio Handlebar Wheelbase Purchase? Notes
Exceptional
WOOM 3 16″ $369 13 18.8 -23.8″ Dual Hand 5.25″ 3.34 Mid 720 Online Elastic turning limiter, Reviewed
Islabikes CNOC 16 $349* 13.2 18.8 – 22.6″ Dual Hand w/ Coaster 5″ 3.55 Mid 707 Phone 503-954-2410 CNOC 14 Review
Early Rider Belter $399 13.7 19.5 – 12″ Dual Hand 5.5″ Low 680 Online Belt Drive, Reviewed
Spawn Banshee $350 15 18.5 – 23.5″ Dual Hand Mid 686 Online Ships from Canada
Highly Recommended
Pello Revo 16″ $299 16.3 20 – 24″ Dual Hand w/ Coaster 5.5″ 3.55 Mid 705 Online Wider, knobby tires
Ridgeback Dimensions $349 16 20.5 – 25.5″ Dual Hand 6.75″ 4.5 Low Online Review in Progress
Cleary Bikes Hedgehog $285 16 19 – 26″ Dual Hand 3.02 Flat 708 Online Very aggressive geometry
Norco Samuari $265 17.9 20.25 – 22″ Dual Hand 6.25″ 3.9 Low 710 Bike Shop Review in Progress
ByK E-350 $259 17.6+ Front w/Coaster 6.25″ Low 800 Online  Review in Progress
Priority Start F/W $259 17 19 – 23.5″ Dual Hand Low Online  Belt Drive, Reviewed
Commencal Ramones 16 $250* 17.8 20.5 – 24″ Dual Hand 7.25″ 3.56 Low 700 Online  Review in Progress
Stampede Bikes Sprinter 16 $239 17.9 22 – 26″ Dual Hand 3.56 Low 749 Online  Reviewed
Recommended
Specialized Hotrock 16″ Coaster $240 19 19 – 23″ Coaster Low Bike Shop
Trek Superfly 16 $309 18 19.5 – 24″ Coaster 6″ 3.25 Low 737 Bike Shop Review in Progress, Really wide handlebars
Cannondale Trail/Tango 16 $240 20.11 Coaster Low  746 Bike Shop
Recommended with Reservations
Raleigh MXR 16 $189 Coaster  3.5 High Bike Shop
Raleigh Jazzi 16 $189 Coaster  3.5 High Bike Shop
Haro Z 16 $209 23.5 Rear Hand w/ Coaster 4.0 Mid Bike Shop
Fuji Kit 16 $230 24.33 Coaster Mid  748 Bike Shop
Trek Jet 16 $220 22.5 20″ – Coaster High Bike Shop
Trek Mystic 16 $209 21.5 Coaster High Bike Shop
Giant Animator 16 $180 19 21″ – Coaster High Bike Shop
Diamondback Mini Viper 16″ $110  20.8 20 – 24″  Coaster  3.5  High  758 Online  Reviewed
Diamondback Mini Impression $159  Coaster  2.9  High  747 Online
Not Recommended
Next Rocket 16″ $40 19 22.5 – 23.5″ Coaster  6.5″ 3.5 High 685 WalMart  Comparison review
Bikestar Classic 16 $189 29 21 – 24″ Front Hand w/ Coaster Mid 715 Online
Royal Baby 16″ BMX $87 24.2 20.9 – 25.6″  Front Hand w/ Coaster  Mid 749 Online Reviewed
RoyalBaby 18″ BMX $129 26.4 21.7 – 27.6″  Front Hand w/ Coaster  Mid 807 Online

Explanations and What to Look For on Comparison Chart

Weight: The lighter the better, a bike less than 30% of a child’s weight is ideal.  16″ bikes are a great fit for 4 year-olds in at least 4T pants (always be sure to measure your child’s inseam first)!
Chainring/Cassette: The number of teeth on the cogs.  Chainring is in the front, cassette in the back.  See gain ratio on how these affect how easy it is to pedal the bike.
Wheelbase: Plays largely into the geometry of the bike.  A longer wheelbase, with a short minimum seat height and taller handlebars are ideal for timid riders.  A longer wheelbase, with a taller minimum seat height and lower rise handlebars creates a more aggressive position on the bike.
Bottom Bracket Height:  A lower bottom bracket allows for a lower center-of-gravity for the rider and also allows for a lower minimum seat height.
Crank Arms: Shorter cranks arm go hand in hand with a lower bottom bracket height (to prevent pedals from hitting the ground while turning).  A shorter crank arm is generally paired with smaller chainrings to compensate for less torque they offer on the chainrings (to allow for easier pedaling).
Gain Ratio: There are several methods on how to measure how hard or easy it is to pedal a bike.  Gain ratio uses the tires radius (essentially the same for all 16″ tires), the crank length as well as the number of teeth on the chainring and cassette.  For every inch the pedals orbit around the bottom bracket, the bike will travel the gain ratio’s distance in inches. The lower the gain ratio the easier it is to start pedaling the bike but the faster they have to pedal to ride faster.
Seat Height: The lower the better as it allows a child to ride a larger wheel size.  A beginning rider’s inseam should be no more than 1″ less than the minimum seat height.  This allows them to touch the ground with their feet to stop and helps them feel more comfortable on the bike when learning.  Really timid riders are better off with their full foot on the ground, so their inseam should match the bike minimum seat height.  Experienced riders only need their tippy toes to touch the ground and can ride a bike with a minimum seat height 2″ taller than their inseam.
Brakes: When learning to ride, kids naturally pedal backwards.  Coaster brakes can cause the bike stop unexpectedly, leading to falls, which can frighten kids and delays mastering pedaling.  As a result, bikes without coaster are best for beginners, but only if they are comfortable using hand brakes.  Essentially all higher-end online bikes use easy-pull, small-reach brake levers which make braking easy for small hands.  For bikes with dual hand brakes, it is very important to teach kids to brake with their right hand (rear brake) versus just the left (which can cause endo).  Putting colored tape on the right brake lever can help them learn which one to use.  The WOOM3 comes with a green brake lever on the right to help kids differentiate.
Handlebars: Beginning riders are better off with handlebars with a medium rise (around 100 mm).  Aggressive riders, who plan on riding on jumps or single-track, are better off with a flatter handlebar with a lower rise (around 60 mm or below).  Bars with a really high rise, such as the Next Rocket at 230 mm, put kids hands in an awkward and poor position for handling.
Online: Is the bike available online or only in bike shops.

  • Kim

    Hi Natalie! I’m looking for a 16″ bike on Craigslist, my husband and I are thinking of putting more $ into our just turned 5 yo son’s next bike. So far we’ve found the Diamondback Mini Viper and the Giant Animator. Any thoughts on which one you would choose? He is a balance bike grad and currently is riding a Diamondback Micro Viper but it’s too small! Thanks in advance and thanks for your awesome website!

    • Between those two, I would go with the Diamonback Mini Viper. The Giant Animator has tall handlebars that were problematic for my son when he test rode the bike.

      • Kim

        Thanks Natalie, for always sharing your wealth of information 🙂 I’ve seen a few 16″ Hotrocks too.. Diamondback vs Hotrock?